Skip to main content

Tax software failed before 31 January: what to do

Barry McGee, landlord and founder of LetbookLast updated 12 Nov 2026

If your software fails just before or while you prepare an online Self Assessment return, HMRC's own manual lists that as a possible reasonable excuse for a late return. It is not automatic: you must file without unreasonable delay once the problem ends, and HMRC's guide treats "within 14 days" as the usual measure.

A late 2025-26 return costs an initial £100 penalty, so the aim is to file by 11:59pm on 31 January 2027, through HMRC's own online service if your software is down, and to keep evidence if you cannot. Facts below are from HMRC's guidance as it read on 12 November 2026.

  • Tax software failed before 31 January: reasonable excuse? (UK)

What HMRC's manual says

HMRC's Compliance Handbook gives examples of a reasonable excuse. One is: "the person's computer or software failed just before or while they were preparing their online return". Source: CH160300, Reasonable excuse: examples, HMRC Compliance Handbook (opens in a new tab).

The Self Assessment Manual explains the test: "A reasonable excuse is normally something that stopped the customer from meeting a tax obligation on time that they took reasonable care to meet." There is no legal definition. Each case turns on its facts. Source: SAM10090, reasonable excuse, Self Assessment Manual.

FigureWhat the source saysSource
Deadline"You must submit your online tax return by 11:59pm on 31 January 2027" (2025-26 return)Deadlines, GOV.UK
Initial penalty"an initial £100 penalty"Penalties, GOV.UK
Unreasonable delay"As a guide, 'unreasonable delay' would be within 14 days"SAM10090
Time to appeal"usually 30 days from the date of the letter"Disagree with a tax decision or penalty, GOV.UK

What does not help

The same manual lists excuses an HMRC officer should not accept. "Tax return too difficult" is one: the customer "should have taken early steps to contact HMRC or a tax adviser". "Failure by agent would not normally be treated as a reasonable excuse." So if a software package is hard to use, or an adviser is late, those are not the same as a failure of the software itself. Source: SAM10090.

HMRC's manual says the excuse must have ended before the clock starts: "Once a reasonable excuse has ended, the customer must submit the outstanding return or make payment without unreasonable delay."

What to do when the software fails

  1. Note the date and time and what happened. Screenshots of the error help.
  2. Contact the software provider and keep the reply. HMRC's guide to correcting returns says to "Contact the software provider for help" with commercial software. Source: If you need to change your return, GOV.UK.
  3. File through HMRC's own online service before the deadline if you can: File your Self Assessment tax return online.
  4. If the deadline passes, file as soon as the problem ends, within 14 days.
  5. When the penalty notice arrives, appeal in writing and give the dates. HMRC says: "If you have a reasonable excuse, you can appeal against a penalty." Source: Self Assessment penalties, GOV.UK.

Late tax is a separate matter. A reasonable excuse for a late return does not mean the tax is not due on 31 January. The full penalty ladder is in Self Assessment 31 January 2027 for landlords.

Making Tax Digital in 2026-27

For landlords already in Making Tax Digital, HMRC says: "HMRC will not apply penalty points for late quarterly updates during the 2026 to 2027 tax year." It adds: "Penalty points will still apply for late tax returns for this tax year." Source: Send quarterly updates, GOV.UK. The quarterly dates are in MTD quarterly updates for landlords.

Frequently asked questions

Is a software crash a reasonable excuse? It can be. HMRC's manual lists "computer or software failed just before or while they were preparing their online return" as an example, and each case is judged on its facts.

How fast must I file after the problem ends? Without unreasonable delay. HMRC's guide says that would be within 14 days, unless another time limit applies.

How long do I have to appeal a penalty? HMRC's guide says usually 30 days from the date of the letter.

Keep the figures ready before the deadline

Letbook is a compliance tracker for landlords. It records rent and expenses by property for each tax year, estimates the tax and, on Premium, exports a CSV by HMRC category, so the figures are ready whichever software files the return. Letbook does not file with HMRC. Sign up free.

Sources

  • CH160300, Reasonable excuse: examples, HMRC Compliance Handbook
  • SAM10090, reasonable excuse, HMRC Self Assessment Manual
  • Self Assessment penalties, GOV.UK
  • Disagree with a tax decision or penalty, GOV.UK
  • Send quarterly updates, GOV.UK

Facts checked on 12 November 2026.